Group health insurance in India is optional for most private employers, but the ESI scheme sitting next to it is not, and mixing the two up is where budgets go wrong. Get it wrong and you pay for overlapping cover, miss an 18% GST line, or leave a statutory contribution unpaid. Map the mandatory layer first, then price the voluntary policy on top of it.
That order matters more than any insurer’s brochure. A policy built before you know who falls under ESI is a policy you’ll rebuild within a year.
ESI is the mandatory layer, and a private group policy doesn’t replace it for staff who are covered. Employees with monthly wages up to ₹21,000 are generally inside the scheme, and the ceiling rises to ₹25,000 for persons with disabilities, according to ClearTax’s ESI rate guide. The employer pays 3.25% of wages and the employee pays 0.75%.
Whether ESI applies to your team also depends on headcount and on how your state has notified the scheme. Our guide to ESI contribution in India walks through the registration side.
Consider a Pune support team of fifteen, where three people earn ₹19,000 a month and the other twelve earn ₹45,000 or more. The three sit inside ESI. The twelve don’t, so a group policy is their only employer funded medical cover. One workforce, two groups, and your policy document has to say so plainly.
And yes, the same person can hold both. ESI and a private policy can run side by side. What you shouldn’t do is count the ESI contribution as your “health benefit” in an offer letter and stop there.
Budget the premium plus 18% GST, because group and corporate policies didn’t get the exemption that individual policies received. After 22 September 2025, individual health plans, family floaters and senior citizen policies became GST exempt, while Tata Capital’s GST explainer notes that group and corporate plans continue to attract 18%.
Input tax credit is the next trap. The same source says credit on employee health insurance is generally blocked under Section 17(5)(b) of the CGST Act, though it may be available where the cover is mandatory under a law. In plain terms, treat the GST as a cost and not as a credit, then confirm with your tax advisor.
The employee side is kinder. A TaxGuru practical note on salary under the Income Tax Act, 2025, effective 1 April 2026, states that employer paid health insurance within the notified limits continues to be a tax free perquisite. Stay inside those limits and the premium doesn’t land in taxable salary. Step outside them and it can. Ask your payroll team to check the current limits before you finalise a sum insured.
The two schemes differ on who must join, who pays and how the tax works. This table puts the differences side by side.
| Point | ESI | Private group policy |
|---|---|---|
| Legal status | Mandatory for covered employees | Voluntary unless your contract or policy promises it |
| Who is eligible | Generally wages up to ₹21,000 a month (₹25,000 for persons with disabilities) | Whoever you choose, often every employee |
| Employer cost | 3.25% of wages | Negotiated premium plus 18% GST |
| Employee cost | 0.75% of wages | Usually none for the base cover, but parents or extra cover may be employee paid |
| Input tax credit | Not applicable, it is a statutory contribution | Generally blocked under Section 17(5)(b) CGST unless the cover is mandatory by law |
| Employee tax | Contribution handled in payroll | Tax free perquisite within notified limits |
Read the table as a sequence. Fix the ESI column first, because it sets which employees your policy really has to protect.
Most of the cost sits in three choices, and you control all of them. Settle these before you request quotes so insurers price the same thing.
My view is blunt. A cheap policy with a thin sum insured and long waiting periods is worse than no policy, because employees find out at the hospital desk. A modest, clearly explained policy beats a large one nobody understands.
Cover should start when employment starts and end on a date you control. Add each new joiner in the first week, and keep a record of the date. A gap of even a few weeks is the kind of thing employees remember.
Exits need the same discipline. Confirm in writing when cover stops, and match that date to the employee’s last working day and final settlement. If you’re moving a team from one EOR or vendor to another, ask for the policy schedule early, because a change of insurer can reset terms such as waiting periods.
Communication closes the loop. Give every employee a one page note that states the sum insured, who counts as a dependant, how to raise a claim and whom to call when a claim stalls. Keep the policy schedule, the member list and the premium invoices in one folder, because claims queries and GST filing draw on the same documents.
Meanwhile, keep the benefit visible in the salary structure. Our explainer on salary structure and CTC breakup in India shows where insurance, bonus and statutory items sit, and the wider statutory benefits guide covers the rest of the mandatory list.
With an Employer of Record, the EOR is the legal employer, so your team’s health cover is arranged through the EOR and not through a policy you buy yourself. That removes the insurer hunt, but it adds two questions you should ask before signing.
First, is group cover included in the monthly fee, or priced as a separate line? Second, can you see the sum insured, the dependant rules and the waiting periods in writing? A good Employer of Record in India will answer both without hesitation. If you want the wider picture, question 38 in our 50 questions guide to EOR services in India covers how an EOR handles employee health insurance.
By contrast, if you run your own Indian entity, you buy the policy yourself and carry the GST, the insurer relationship and the claims escalations. Neither route is wrong. Pick the one that matches your headcount and your appetite for admin.